I asked ChatGPT, Gemini and Claude for the best SEO for veterinary practices near Philadelphia. For the first time in this series, one of them named Ritner Digital without being asked. It was Claude, and in the same sentence it warned the reader that we wrote the list it found us on.
ChatGPT and Gemini left us out. When I asked why, ChatGPT said it was a gap in its research and pointed out something it had missed: an agency it had just recommended, Web Tonic, ranks us sixth in its own Philadelphia veterinary list. Gemini said the omission wasn't an oversight and defended its list, then made a fair case for where we fit.
This test showed us something the first two didn't. AI assistants are reading the "best agency" lists that agencies publish about themselves, and they handle them very differently. One relied on them without saying so, one used them as evidence after the fact, and one told the buyer not to trust them.
Below are all three conversations in full and unedited, followed by what they show about how AI decides which agencies to recommend, and what veterinary practices should take from it.
How I ran the test
This is part three of a series. In part one, I asked the three AIs what makes Ritner Digital different. In part two, I asked who should do SEO for a commercial truck dealership. None of them named us until I asked why.
This time I used the same format with a different industry:
The buyer's question: "Best SEO for veterinary practices near Philadelphia"
The follow-up, only if we weren't named: "Why didn't Ritner Digital make this list?"
Claude named us in its first answer, so it never got the follow-up. ChatGPT and Gemini both did. Each AI ran once, without custom instructions, and none of the answers have been edited.
I chose veterinary practices because it's a market where we've published a lot. That includes a list of the best veterinary marketing agencies in the U.S. with Ritner Digital at number one, and a clear disclosure that we're the ones publishing it. That list turned out to matter a lot.
ChatGPT: "A gap in my research"
ChatGPT's first answer named three Philadelphia-area agencies: 1SEO Digital Agency, Web Tonic and Sagapixel. After the follow-up, it called leaving us out "a gap in my research" and admitted its original list hadn't been researched well enough.
What stood out to me:
The strategy advice in its first answer was strong. ChatGPT recommended starting with Google Maps visibility and the three to five services that bring in the most valuable new-patient appointments. It gave keyword groups from "vet near me" to urgent and specialty searches, warned against targeting services a practice doesn't actually offer, and cited Google's own guidance against repetitive location pages.
It caught its own contradiction. In the follow-up, ChatGPT found that Web Tonic's Philadelphia veterinary list, from an agency it had just recommended, ranks Ritner Digital sixth. In other words, it left out an agency that one of its own picks had already vouched for.
It was honest about what's missing. It said it had found reported results from our truck dealership work but hadn't verified comparable results for veterinary clients. That's accurate. We don't have a published veterinary case study yet.
It criticized its own method. ChatGPT said the bigger problem was that it had presented three agencies as a "best-of" list without any real comparison or consistent selection criteria. That's a good warning about AI-generated shortlists in general.
One detail to note: ChatGPT reported that Web Tonic lists our starting pricing at $1,000 a month. That number comes from Web Tonic's page, and I come back to it below.
Gemini: "It wasn't left off out of oversight"
Gemini was the only AI in this test that defended its first answer. It said its table was a small sample of agencies with either long veterinary track records or large in-house teams, and that we weren't left off by mistake.
What stood out to me:
Its first list mixed two kinds of agencies. Gemini named two Philadelphia agencies (SEO Locale and 1Digital Agency) and three national veterinary-only firms (Beyond Indigo Pets, Vetcelerator and LifeLearn). It then explained when each kind makes sense. That's a helpful way for a practice owner to think about the decision.
It drew a fair comparison. In the follow-up, Gemini described us as a founder-led boutique where you work directly with the strategist, focused heavily on AI search alongside Google Business Profile and local search. It compared that with SEO Locale's 20+ in-house specialists and with large national vet-only teams.
It called us a generalist, and that's correct. Gemini noted that we cover veterinary marketing and appear on Web Tonic's Philadelphia guide, but that we're a general SEO and content agency, not a veterinary-only firm. A practice owner should know that.
It ended with a clear recommendation. For a practice that wants a nimble local partner, direct founder involvement and a focus on AI search, Gemini said we're well worth including on the shortlist.
Gemini's first answer also included advice I agree with: pet owners increasingly ask AI tools for vet recommendations, so practices need clean schema markup, clear FAQs and consistent directory listings. That applies to agencies too, as this test shows.
Claude: "Read them as marketing"
Claude named Ritner Digital first in its list of Philadelphia-area options, without being prompted. It also gave the most skeptical answer of the three. It opened by saying nearly every "best veterinary SEO agency" list it found was published by an agency that ranks itself near the top, so those lists should be read as marketing.
What stood out to me:
It named us and disclosed the source in the same breath. Claude described Ritner Digital as a Philadelphia-based SEO and AI search practice, then noted that we're also the agency that wrote the list where it found us. That's exactly the right caveat, and I'd rather be recommended that way than without it.
It looked for agreement across publishers. For national firms, Claude pointed to names that appear on lists from unrelated publishers, such as Beyond Indigo Pets, InTouch Practice Communications, GeniusVets, VetMatrix and Digital Empathy. Agreement among independent sources is more trustworthy than any one ranking.
It described other agencies accurately. It said J2 is known more for branding than SEO and that 1Digital Agency is a generalist that focuses mainly on ecommerce. Those are the kinds of distinctions a practice owner needs.
It flagged something the others missed. Claude noted that veterinary marketing has to follow advertising ethics rules on claims and testimonials. It also said practices should judge reports by new-client exams booked, not just rankings or traffic.
Claude was also the only AI that cited its sources in a list at the end, including our own page and Web Tonic's. You can see exactly where its answer came from.
Side by side
Three AIs, three different outcomes. One named us without being asked, one added us and called the omission a mistake, and one added us while defending its first list.
The names that came up more than once were 1Digital Agency (Gemini and Claude), Beyond Indigo Pets (Gemini and Claude), and Web Tonic, which ChatGPT recommended and Claude cited as a source. Across all three, no single agency appeared in every first answer.
What this test taught us: AI reads the lists agencies write about themselves
Agency "best of" lists are everywhere, and almost all of them have the same structure: the publisher ranks itself first. That's true of Web Tonic's Philadelphia veterinary list, which puts Web Tonic first and was written and reviewed by its own staff. It's also true of our national veterinary list, which puts us first and says so plainly.
This test showed that the AIs are reading those lists, and that each one treats them differently:
Claude found us through our own list and told the reader so. That's the best outcome I could ask for. We're visible, and the buyer knows to weigh the source.
ChatGPT used a competitor's list as evidence after the fact. Web Tonic ranking us sixth was what convinced it we belonged. A mention on someone else's list carried more weight than anything on our own site.
Gemini referenced the same Web Tonic guide when describing us, but still treated us as a generalist rather than a specialist.
Where the $1,000 figure came from
In part one, Gemini said we publish starting pricing of about $1,000 a month, and I couldn't find where it got that. Now I know. Web Tonic's Philadelphia list says Ritner Digital publishes starting retainer pricing "from USD $1,000/month." Its FAQ adds that the figure is an anchor, not a market rate.
That's a useful lesson. One sentence on one third-party page ended up in two different AI answers, in two different tests. Whatever other sites say about your business, including your prices, can become part of how AI describes you.
Third-party mentions beat self-promotion, but both count
Our own list got us named by Claude. Web Tonic's list got us added by ChatGPT. Compare that with part two. There, nothing outside our own case study connected us to truck dealerships, and no AI named us. Here, pages on two different sites connected "Ritner Digital" to "veterinary," and one AI named us without being asked. The difference wasn't our skills. It was how many pages, on how many sites, made the connection.
What veterinary practices should take from this
If you run a veterinary practice in or around Philadelphia, the three AIs agreed on more than they disagreed. Here's the advice worth keeping, whoever you hire.
Start with your Google Business Profile. All three put map results first. ChatGPT pointed to Google's own guidance that local rankings depend on relevance, distance and prominence. Gemini and Claude both said the map results decide whether you show up for "vet near me." Reviews are part of that. In a BrightLocal survey cited by LifeLearn, 40% of people said online reviews were very important when choosing pet care services, and another 32% said they were important.
Build one page per real service. Dental, wellness, vaccinations, surgery, urgent care, exotics: give each one its own page, and only for services you actually provide. ChatGPT specifically warned against targeting emergency or specialty searches you don't offer.
Don't create dozens of near-identical town pages. Optimize around your actual location and the nearby communities you really serve.
Measure booked exams, not traffic. ChatGPT and Claude both said reports should track new-patient appointments, not just rankings.
Know your ethics rules. Claude was the only one to flag that veterinary advertising has rules on claims and testimonials. Ask any agency how they handle them.
Decide between local and vet-only. Gemini's framing is useful. A local agency knows your neighborhoods and suburbs. A veterinary-only national agency knows your terminology and booking software. Pick based on your bigger gap.
Read agency lists as marketing. That includes ours. Look for names that show up on lists from unrelated publishers, and ask for veterinary case studies from competitive markets.
Ask AI about your own practice. Pet owners are asking ChatGPT, Gemini and Claude for vet recommendations. Run the same kind of test for "best vet near [your town]" and see whether your practice appears.
What I'm taking from it
Three tests in, the pattern is clear. AI recommends the businesses it can connect to the question, and those connections come from pages across the web, not just your own website.
Part one showed that AI describes you differently depending on which pages it reads.
Part two showed that strong proof on your own site isn't enough if nothing else links you to the category.
Part three showed that when several sites connect you to a category, AI starts naming you, with or without a follow-up question.
The gap all three AIs pointed to is real: we don't have a published veterinary case study. Lists can get us onto a shortlist. Results are what should keep us there.
Does AI recommend your business?
If a customer asked ChatGPT, Gemini or Claude for the best business like yours in your area, would you be on the list? I'll run this test for your business and industry across the major AI assistants. I'll show you who gets recommended, whether you appear, which sources the AIs rely on, and what it would take to be named in the first answer.
Frequently asked questions
What is the best SEO agency for veterinary practices near Philadelphia?
There's no independent ranking. In this test, the AIs named local agencies (1SEO Digital Agency, Web Tonic, Sagapixel, SEO Locale, 1Digital Agency, J2 and Ritner Digital) and national veterinary-only firms (Beyond Indigo Pets, Vetcelerator, LifeLearn, InTouch Practice Communications, GeniusVets, VetMatrix and Digital Empathy). Compare proposals, ask for veterinary case studies and check references.
Why did Claude recommend Ritner Digital when ChatGPT and Gemini didn't?
Claude found Ritner Digital through our own national veterinary agency list and told the reader we published it. ChatGPT and Gemini built their first lists from other sources, and added us after the follow-up question.
Are "best agency" lists trustworthy?
Treat them as marketing. Most are published by an agency that ranks itself first, including Web Tonic's Philadelphia listand ours. Names that appear on lists from several unrelated publishers are a better signal.
How much does Ritner Digital charge for veterinary SEO?
Web Tonic's list reports our starting pricing as $1,000 a month and describes it as an anchor, not a market rate. For pricing based on your practice, get in touch.
Does Ritner Digital only work with veterinary practices?
No. We're a general SEO and AI search practice that works with veterinary practices, local businesses and B2B companies. If you want a veterinary-only agency, the national firms named above specialize exclusively in animal hospitals.
What should veterinary SEO focus on first?
Your Google Business Profile and reviews, then a dedicated page for each service you actually offer. All three AIs agreed that map visibility decides whether you show up for "vet near me" searches.
Do pet owners use AI to find a vet?
Gemini said pet owners increasingly ask AI tools for vet recommendations, and advised practices to use clear schema, FAQs and consistent directory listings so AI can recommend them. Testing your own practice is the best way to find out what those tools are saying about you.
What were parts one and two of this series?
Part one asked what makes Ritner Digital different. Part two asked who should do SEO for a commercial truck dealership.
Sources
Philadelphia Veterinary Marketing Agencies, Reviewed for 2026 (Web Tonic)
12 Best Veterinary Marketing Agencies in the U.S. (2026) (Ritner Digital)
Google reviews and pet care services, citing BrightLocal (LifeLearn)
Part one: We Asked ChatGPT, Gemini, and Claude What Makes Ritner Digital Different (Ritner Digital)
Part two: We Asked ChatGPT, Gemini, and Claude Who Should Do SEO for a Commercial Truck Dealership(Ritner Digital)