Three AI assistants got the same question about Ritner Digital and gave three different answers. Not one competitor appeared on all three lists. Two of them even disagreed about what makes us different in the first place.
In mid-November 2026, I typed the same question, word for word, into ChatGPT, Gemini and Claude:
"What would you say is Ritner Digital's differentiator compared to competitors, and who are its nearest competitors?"
I run an AI search and SEO practice. Getting businesses to show up well in answers like these is the job. So when a prospect asks an AI assistant about us, what it says matters as much as where we rank on Google, and maybe more.
The data backs that up. When Pew Research Center studied the real browsing activity of 900 U.S. adults, people who saw a Google AI summary clicked a regular search result in 8% of visits. Without a summary, they clicked 15% of the time. Clicks on the links inside the summary itself happened in only about 1% of visits (Search Engine Journal). More and more, the AI's answer is where the buying decision gets shaped.
Below are all three answers in full and unedited, followed by what I learned from comparing them. Some of it was flattering, some of it was wrong, and most of it was useful. All of it applies to your business too, because the same thing happens every time your customers ask an AI about you.
How I ran the test
I kept it simple on purpose, so the answers would look like what a real buyer might see:
The same prompt. I copied the identical question into each assistant.
One run each. No follow-up questions, no rephrasing, no custom instructions steering the answer.
No edits. The embeds below show each answer as it came back, including the parts I disagree with.
One caveat before you read them. A single run per tool is a snapshot, not a measurement. In a study by Rand Fishkin of SparkToro and Patrick O'Donnell of Gumshoe.ai, about 600 volunteers ran 12 identical prompts through ChatGPT, Claude and Google's AI nearly 3,000 times. The odds of getting the same list of brands twice were under 1 in 100. The odds of the same list in the same order were about 1 in 1,000 (Search Engine Land).
So treat these three answers as three samples of what a buyer might read on a given day, not a fixed verdict. That variability turned out to be the most interesting part of the experiment.
ChatGPT: "Marketing built around how people search, think, and choose"
ChatGPT answered like a strategy consultant. It said our differentiator isn't SEO or AI search on their own. It's where three things meet: buyer psychology, search visibility, and strategy carried out by the person you actually talk to.
What stood out to me:
It called AI search "table stakes." ChatGPT pointed out that every competitor it named already advertises AI search work. Its blunt conclusion was that calling ourselves an "AI Search & SEO Agency" tells people what we do but not why they should pick us. That stung a little, and it's right.
It got the case study numbers right, caveats included. It cited our True Blue Autos case study accurately: 48% more Google clicks and 93% more impressions over comparable 30-day periods. It also noted, correctly, that these are search gains rather than verified revenue. That's exactly how our homepage describes them.
Its competitors were small and close to home. ChatGPT named boutique shops with a similar business model rather than big agencies. Workbench SEO is a real match: clients work directly with its two founders, Alex and Carmen, and it serves businesses in Pennsylvania and New Jersey. TJA Strategies, founded in 2025 in Wynnewood, PA, promises to get businesses found on Google, the map pack and AI search. That's close to our own pitch.
It wrote us a positioning line. "Marketing built around how people search, think, and choose" is a better tagline than some I've paid for.
ChatGPT's advice was the most useful of the three. It said to turn the psychology background into a visible method, to show how the channels work together in one case study, and to narrow the audience over time.
Gemini: "AI search as the centerpiece, not an add-on"
Gemini took nearly the opposite view. It named generative engine optimization (GEO), meaning work to get a business mentioned in AI-generated answers, as the core of what makes Ritner Digital different. It said that most older agencies treat AI visibility as an extension of SEO, while we build around it.
What stood out to me:
It compared us to much bigger agencies. Gemini's list leaned toward established, larger firms. Seer Interactivewas founded in 2002, is B Corp certified and has been publishing AI search research since January 2023. Being mentioned next to Seer is flattering. But Gemini was grouping us by category (who does AI search work in Philadelphia), not by size or budget, and it said so in its comparison table.
It credited transparency, then added a detail I can't find. Gemini praised us for publishing research and benchmark data. It also said we publish starting pricing of around $1,000 a month. Our homepage doesn't list pricing; it sends people to a contact form. I don't know where Gemini got that figure. An AI repeating a specific, confident detail that isn't on your site is exactly the kind of thing a business needs to catch early.
It treated our industries as a strength. Gemini described our work with dealerships, home services, multi-location businesses and veterinary practices as proven playbooks. The other two assistants saw the same range of industries as a focus problem.
No overlap with ChatGPT. None of Gemini's competitors (Seer, Nectiv, Sagefrog, Eastern Standard, Omniscient Digital, First Page Sage, 1SEO and WebFX) appeared in ChatGPT's answer.
Gemini's closing line was the cleanest summary of who we're for: a business that wants a transparent, specialized partner focused on rankings and AI citations, without big-agency overhead.
Claude: "Radical transparency"
Claude gave the most heavily cited answer and the most skeptical one. It said our clearest advantage is that we publish our own search results as public proof. It quoted our homepage tagline about being the firm "that publishes its numbers," along with our view that in AI search, being easy for a model to summarize beats being big.
What stood out to me:
It named a real weakness. Claude said our positioning is spread thin. Our homepage speaks to local, owner-run businesses. Other posts pitch B2B pipeline work, diagnostics for private-equity operating partners, veterinary practices and credit unions. Its advice was to pick one main buyer. ChatGPT said almost the same thing in different words.
It sorted competitors into groups. First came small Philadelphia shops focused on AI search, such as BCC Interactive, SEO Locale and SEOM. Next were industry specialists we'd meet if we went deeper into a niche, such as Sagapixel in healthcare and NextLeft in credit unions. Last were larger firms like Seer, Greenlane and WebFX.
It disclosed where its information came from. This was the most important sentence in all three answers. Claude noted that most of what's online about Ritner Digital, including the competitor lists, comes from our own blog, so it reflects our framing rather than an independent assessment.
That last point is fair, and you can see it in the sources. Claude's competitor list closely matches our post on the 12 top AI search companies in Philadelphia. It also matches the agencies named in an earlier post about Claude recommending us(SEOM, Padula Media, LocalMighty, FZP Digital and Jason Shaffer SEO). We published clear, structured content about our market, and an AI used it to describe us. That shows the method works. It also shows the limit of describing yourself without independent sources to back you up.
Where all three agreed
The competitor lists barely overlap, but underneath them the three assistants agreed on more than I expected. Those shared points matter most, because they're what a buyer will likely hear whichever tool they use.
You work with the person doing the work. All three described us as a small, founder-led practice where clients deal directly with the person doing the work. ChatGPT also warned that this alone won't set us apart from other boutiques.
Transparency is real. ChatGPT pointed to our published reporting, "including declines as well as gains." Gemini credited our published benchmarks. Claude made transparency the headline.
AI search is central to who we are. They disagreed about whether that makes us unique, but none of them described us as a traditional SEO shop.
Proof is still thin. ChatGPT called our public portfolio "relatively limited." Claude pointed out that most of the information comes from us. Neither claimed we had verified revenue results, which is accurate.
Focus is an open question. ChatGPT said to narrow the audience. Claude said to pick one main buyer. Gemini liked the range of industries. All three were looking at the same thing: we currently serve several kinds of clients.
If I had to summarize the agreement in one line, it would be this: a credible, transparent, hands-on practice that still needs to prove itself more widely and choose a lane.
Where they disagreed: three different competitive sets
Across the three answers, the AIs named more than 20 different agencies as our competitors. No agency appeared in all three. ChatGPT and Gemini didn't share a single name.
The only overlaps:
ChatGPT and Claude both named BCC Interactive, SEO Locale and Sagapixel.
Gemini and Claude both named Seer Interactive and WebFX.
The disagreement about AI search is the one I find most useful. ChatGPT and Gemini can both be right: AI search is at the center of what we do, and it's also no longer rare. A company can't build a lasting advantage on something every competitor also offers.
Why the same question got three different answers
The assistants weren't broken. Each one built its answer from different material and understood "competitor" differently. Four things explain most of the gap.
1. They read different pages. Each assistant searches the web and picks a handful of pages to work from. Claude relied heavily on our own blog plus a LenGreo roundup of ChatGPT marketing agencies in Philadelphia. Gemini cited our site and LenGreo. ChatGPT seems to have spent more time on competitors' websites. Different pages produce different answers.
2. They defined "competitor" differently. ChatGPT looked for agencies with the same business model: small, founder-led, serving local service businesses. Gemini looked at the category and market tier, which pulled in larger firms. Claude looked at which agencies tend to show up on the same lists we do. All three approaches are reasonable, and they produce three different lists.
3. AI answers vary by design. Language models produce answers by probability, so even the same tool gives different answers to the same question. The SparkToro and Gumshoe.ai research found that individual rankings were mostly noise. Overall visibility held up better: in some categories, certain brands appeared in 60% to 90% of responses even as their positions moved around. Smaller markets also produced steadier results than large ones (Search Engine Land).
4. We're new, so there's less to go on. Ritner Digital launched in January 2026. Young businesses have little independent coverage, so the AIs rely heavily on what the business says about itself. Where nothing covers a question, an AI may fill the gap with something that sounds right, like a starting price.
What this means for your business
If three AI assistants can describe a company that works on AI visibility for a living in three different ways, they're probably doing the same with yours. Here's what I'd do about it.
Ask the AIs about yourself, more than once. Ask ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude and Perplexity who your competitors are, what makes you different and what you cost. Ask a few times, in a few different ways. Since lists rarely repeat, one answer tells you little. A pattern across many answers tells you a lot.
Look for confident mistakes. The most dangerous answer isn't a missing mention. It's a specific, believable detail that's wrong, like a price, a service you don't offer or a market you don't serve. Fix it at the source by stating the correct information clearly on your own site.
Write the sentence you want the AI to repeat. If your positioning changes from one page to the next, the AI has to choose for you. Pick one clear description of who you serve and why you're different, and use it consistently everywhere.
Earn mentions outside your own website. Claude was right that self-published content only goes so far. Reviews, directory listings, press coverage, podcast appearances and other people's roundups give AI tools a second opinion to cite.
Track whether you appear, not your position. Because rankings inside AI answers are so unstable, the useful question is how often you show up for the questions your buyers ask, and whether you're described correctly when you do.
Remember your competitors may not be who you think. Each AI drew a different competitive map for us. Your buyers are seeing those maps too. Knowing which businesses you're being compared against is useful for messaging, pricing and sales conversations.
What I'm taking from it
This experiment gave me free feedback from three very well-read critics. Here's what I'm changing.
Leading with the method, not the channel. "AI search" says what we do. How we do it is the more lasting answer: starting from how buyers search, what they're unsure about and what makes them trust a business, then connecting every channel to that decision.
Choosing a primary buyer. Two of the three assistants flagged this without being asked. Variety in the portfolio is fine. A homepage that speaks to everyone is not.
Building proof beyond our own website. More case studies that connect visibility to inquiries, and more third-party coverage, so the next AI answer has independent sources to work from.
Publishing the numbers anyway. Transparency was the one strength all three recognized. I'll keep sharing the declines along with the gains.
I'll run this same test again in a few months and publish the comparison, whether the answers get better or worse.
Want to know what AI is saying about your business?
If you've never asked ChatGPT, Gemini or Claude who your competitors are, you may not know what your buyers are being told. I can run this test for your business across the major AI assistants. I'll show you where you appear, how you're described, who you're compared with and what's wrong, then build a plan to fix it.
Frequently asked questions
Why do ChatGPT, Gemini and Claude give different answers to the same question?
Each assistant searches different web pages, weighs sources differently and generates text by probability. Even the same tool rarely repeats itself. In SparkToro and Gumshoe.ai's research, the odds of getting the same list of brands twice were under 1 in 100 (Search Engine Land).
Who are Ritner Digital's competitors?
It depends on who you ask, and that's the point of this post. The AIs named small Philadelphia-area search boutiques like BCC Interactive, SEO Locale and Workbench SEO. They also named industry specialists like Sagapixel and larger firms like Seer Interactive and WebFX. The full lists are in the comparison table above.
What makes Ritner Digital different?
All three AIs agreed on transparency (we publish our own search performance, declines included) and on direct access to the person doing the work. ChatGPT added the psychology-led approach to how buyers search and choose. That combination is where we're heading.
Is the pricing Gemini mentioned accurate?
Gemini said we publish starting pricing of around $1,000 a month. Our website doesn't list pricing. For current pricing on a visibility audit, a monthly partnership or a one-off project, get in touch.
What is generative engine optimization (GEO)?
GEO is the work of making a business visible and accurately described in AI-generated answers from tools like ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and Google's AI Overviews. It builds on SEO fundamentals but focuses on being cited and summarized correctly, not just ranked.
How often should a business check what AI says about it?
Monthly is a reasonable rhythm for most businesses, plus a check after any major website or positioning change. Run each question several times across several tools, and look for patterns rather than single answers.
Can you change what AI assistants say about your business?
You can influence it, though you can't control it. Clear, consistent information on your own site, structured content AI tools can easily summarize, and independent mentions elsewhere all improve the chances of being described accurately. Our own experiment shows both sides: AI repeated the framing we published, and also filled gaps with details we never published.
Will AI search replace Google?
Not entirely, but it's changing how people use it. Pew found that Google users who saw an AI summary clicked a regular search result in 8% of visits, compared with 15% when no summary appeared (Pew Research Center). Showing up in the answer itself matters more and more.
Sources
Google users are less likely to click on links when an AI summary appears in the results (Pew Research Center)
Pew Research Confirms Google AI Overviews Is Eroding Web Ecosystem (Search Engine Journal)
AI recommendation lists repeat less than 1% of the time: Study (Search Engine Land)
True Blue Autos commercial truck dealership SEO case study (Ritner Digital)
12 Top AI Search Companies in Philadelphia (2026) (Ritner Digital)
Claude Just Recommended Ritner Digital as an Answer (Ritner Digital)
Workbench SEO profile (Clutch)
TJA Strategies profile (DesignRush)
Official information about Seer Interactive and Seer's GEO services (Seer Interactive)